Llame al (888) 572-7520 para hablar con un agente
Enviar mensaje a un agente
Civil liability litigation has become increasingly costly for businesses, particularly for the trucking industry.
Civil liability litigation has become increasingly costly for businesses, particularly for the trucking industry, due to the rapid rise in jury-awarded damages. An analysis by the American Transportation Research Institute (ATRI) found that so-called “nuclear verdicts” increased significantly in both frequency and size between 2013 and 2022, with the median award reaching $36 million in 2022—50% higher than in 2013. In addition, the share of verdicts exceeding $50 million also increased.
The trucking industry is especially vulnerable to these cases, as traffic accidents are among the leading sources of nuclear verdicts. These costs are ultimately passed on to consumers and the broader economy, contributing to food price inflation and reducing U.S. GDP.
In response to this ongoing pressure, studies such as ATRI’s seek to analyze current trends in verdicts and settlements, given their direct impact on commercial vehicle insurance costs.
Rising litigation: the urgent need for balanced legal reforms
The growth in litigation and jury awards has turned even minor accidents into significant financial risks for the transportation sector, particularly for small and mid-sized fleets. The federally mandated minimum insurance requirement of $750,000—unchanged since the 1980s—is now insufficient in the face of claims that frequently reach tens of millions of dollars.
Data shared by ATRI show sustained growth in civil litigation related to tractor-trailer crashes: between 2014 and 2023, cases increased at an average annual rate of 3.7% across 20 states, slightly outpacing the national growth rate of serious and fatal large-truck crashes (3.6%), according to NHTSA.
Moreover, high damage awards are often weakly correlated with actual medical costs. In more than 80% of verdicts exceeding $1 million, non-economic damages were up to ten times higher than the plaintiffs’ medical expenses. While certain injuries, such as paralysis, psychological disorders, and internal organ damage, produced the highest average awards, they were relatively uncommon within the overall dataset.
The report identifies several factors statistically associated with higher awards, particularly specific types of negligence and injury severity. Regarding negligence:
- Driver use of illegal substances — associated with a 340.7% increase in total damages
- Improper hiring or onboarding practices — associated with a 272.3% increase
Inadequate onboarding was the sole negligence factor in 60% of the cases in which it was alleged, making it the most common single cause of plaintiff awards. Other significant factors included running red lights, failure to stop, and improper parking.
With respect to injuries:
- Fatality cases increased total compensation by more than 380% on average
- Persistent psychological disorders increased awards by 290%
- Severe and moderate traumatic brain injuries increased compensation by 158.9% and 83.8%, respectively
The report concludes by emphasizing the urgent need for balanced legal reforms and warns policymakers about the growing complexity and severity of the current litigation environment. States such as Georgia, Arkansas, and Montana have introduced legislation to curb excessive litigation, while Oklahoma and Iowa have enacted laws imposing caps on non-economic damages to limit excessive awards that, in some cases, vastly exceed actual medical and financial losses. Nevertheless, further reform efforts are needed.
How to avoid ELD violations: common mistakes truckers make
Violations related to Electronic Logging Devices (ELDs) are among the most common issues found during roadside inspections by the Department of Transportation.
Drive your stress away: techniques for truck drivers
Approximately 75% of truck drivers report feeling emotionally stressed at work, and very few have the tools to cope with these situations or seek help.
California vs. Washington: regulatory dispute over trucks in the U.S.
California, the most populous state in the country, wants to remove diesel trucks from its roads. Washington wants exactly the opposite. In between, thousands of fleets are left unsure about which engine to buy.
Volvo Pushes Beyond Diesel with New Hydrogen Combustion Truck Trials
Volvo Trucks is once again taking the lead, beginning road tests with heavy trucks equipped with hydrogen combustion engines.
Trucker Fashion: A Revolution Born on the Road That Still Sets the Trend
Trucker fashion remains relevant due to its authenticity, its seamless integration into streetwear, and its reinterpretation by luxury brands, consolidating itself as a revolution born on the road that evolved from a work uniform into a global cultural symbol
North Dakota among states regaining non-domiciled CDL authority
North Dakota will reissue approximately 150 of the 526 CDLs and CLPs for non-resident drivers that were active during the FMCSA audit.
Business hours: Monday to Friday from 8:00 AM to 5:00 PM. California time