Hiring more experienced drivers involves prioritizing those with clean records and more incident-free years on the roads.
In the course of 2023, the transportation sector faced a persistent shortage of drivers, leading several companies to lower requirements for applicants and hire less experienced drivers to fill vacancies. Although this may seem like an immediate solution, what companies overlook is that these practices can increase business risk, resulting in higher insurance premiums.
The Federal Motor Carrier Safety Administration (FMCSA) regulates the safety of commercial vehicles and, through its Compliance, Safety, and Accountability (CSA) program, imposes high standards on carriers and drivers. The Safety Measurement System (SMS) quantifies safety performance, assessing seven key areas (BASIC) such as unsafe driving and vehicle maintenance. Data is updated monthly online, organized into percentiles based on factors like violations, severity, timeliness, and operations.
Insurers use these percentiles to set premiums, with high values indicating risk and impacting costs and coverage. Companies focused on risk mitigation maintain low percentiles, thus controlling their insurance costs.

Why hire drivers with more experience?
Hiring more experienced drivers involves prioritizing those with clean records and more incident-free years on the roads. This approach helps keep SMS percentiles low, making transportation companies more appealing to insurers.
In addition to obtaining more competitive insurance rates, experienced drivers play a crucial role in reducing overall risk exposure. Those with at least two years of commercial driving experience are considered lower risk due to their ability to handle work challenges and difficult driving conditions more effectively than inexperienced drivers.
An additional recommended measure for transportation companies is to hire a Department of Transportation consultant to oversee and manage FMCSA percentiles. These consultants assist carriers in maintaining compliance with the latest regulations, provide training materials, organize driver qualification files and accident records, and conduct annual driver reviews.
The integration of technology also plays a crucial role in improving driver performance and maintaining standards to reduce insurance rates. Devices such as cameras contribute to safety and performance by detecting dangerous behaviors like speeding and the use of portable devices. Data collected by these cameras facilitate the development of training programs, promoting safe driving behaviors and reducing risk.
Given the volatility of the trucking insurance market, with price fluctuations depending on market conditions, it is essential for carriers to take practical steps to control costs and mitigate risks. This includes reducing FMCSA percentiles, improving driver performance, and ensuring compliance.

Trucking in Alaska and Hawaii: How America’s Non‑Contiguous States Break the Mold
When you step outside the contiguous U.S. and look at Alaska and Hawaii, the trucking industry becomes a very different story

FMCSA updates its coercion rule for drivers facing HOS and ELD pressure
The FMCSA’s updated guidance explains that the “coercion rule” is intended to protect commercial motor vehicle drivers.

New York Can Suspend Driver’s Licenses Over Tax Debt
New York has once again put the spotlight on driver’s license suspensions tied to unpaid state taxes, a situation that could affect thousands of transportation, delivery, and logistics workers who depend on driving to earn a living. For commercial drivers and CDL operators, the consequences can go far beyond a simple fine.

What you need to know about CVSA’s International Roadcheck 2026
The first annual inspection, as every year, kicks off with the International Roadcheck, also known as DOT Blitz Week. Here’s what you need to know.

Tariff Shock: Why U.S. Freight Demand Is Suddenly Surging
Companies are cutting inventories to avoid rising tariff-related and storage costs, forcing goods to move faster and in smaller batches. The unexpected result: stronger trucking demand

Bot Auto completes its first driverless commercial highway shipment
Bot Auto has completed its first long-distance commercial shipment without a driver in the cab or a remote operator.
